Changes between Version 23 and Version 24 of Internal/PaperReadingGroup

Timestamp:

Sep 6, 2016, 4:53:28 AM (8 years ago)

Author:

jiachen

Comment:

--

Internal/PaperReadingGroup

@@ -92 +92 @@
 
 }}}
-
-
+We can skip the "overall merit", "confidence" and "quality of writing" for our own papers, since the grades should be "double blind".
 
 == During The Meeting ==
 === Give the talk ===
+* Please make sure that the talk is within 25 minutes.
+* Practice the talk before the meeting.
+* You can write notes as hints, but do not read notes.
+* Please also make the assumption that the audience might not have read the paper before (as how you present it in the conference).
+
+=== Listen to the talks ===
+* Try to understand the key points in the talk, no matter if it is in your research topic or not. Some solutions in other fields might also help your solution.
+* Take notes about the flow and questions. Prepare for at least 3 questions to the paper (or to the talk)
 
 === Discuss based on reviews ===
+* Combine your review with the questions you have written down during the talk.
+* We will go through all the reviews to the presented paper one by one.
+* Feel free to ask questions, give comments on both the paper and the talk.
+* ''For everyone'', please comment on: if I want to continue the work, this is how I am going to improve it.
+
 
 === Electronic devices are NOT recommended during the meeting ===
+It is quite obvious that electronic devices (e.g., smartphones, laptops, tablets, etc.) are huge distractions while listening to talks.
+It is not good to focus on your own work while listening to the talks.
+You can definitely bring your laptop for backup materials but please make sure that '''they are out of reach''' whenever you do not need to show the material from the laptop.
+
+We will have devices to show your slides and go through your reviews. If you need any support material, upload it to the Wiki system or send it to me before the meeting.
+
+Prepare a book for the reading group, and write down your notes/comments in the book. Move it to your own page after the meeting, merge it with your review as a conclusion (it is also a good practice).
+
 
 = Before You Start: Register Your Own Page =